Punjab today
Work, water and money in the two Punjabs: farms, factories, debt, drugs and the young who leave.
The two Punjabs today
Side by sidePakistan: 2023 census. India: 2011 census, the last held; the next is due in 2027. Pakistan's Punjab has over four times the land and people of India's, and more than half of all Pakistanis live in it.
Farms in trouble
Indian PunjabWith about 1.5% of India's land, Indian Punjab grows about a sixth of its wheat and much of its rice, sold to the government at guaranteed prices. The wheat-rice cycle that made it rich is now its trap: rice needs flooded fields, the tubewells pump faster than the rain refills them, and in most blocks the water table falls every year.
Farms are small and mechanised, machinery and fertiliser are bought on credit, and many farmers are deep in debt; thousands have taken their own lives since the 1990s. Each autumn the stubble of the rice harvest is burned, and the smoke drifts over Delhi and Lahore.
The canal country
Pakistani PunjabPakistani Punjab grows most of Pakistan's wheat, cotton, sugarcane and rice on the canal system the British built and Pakistan extended. Much of the land is held in large estates by landlord families, and the tenants and labourers who work it are among the country's poorest. Water is short at the tail of the canals, and the same falling groundwater threatens both Punjabs.
Mills and workshops
Ludhiana knits sweaters and makes bicycles, sewing machines and machine parts; Jalandhar makes sports goods and leather; Mandi Gobindgarh rolls steel. Across the border Faisalabad is Pakistan's textile capital; Sialkot makes footballs for World Cups and surgical instruments for the world's hospitals; Gujranwala makes fans, ceramics and metal goods; Lahore has everything from software to cars.
Leaving home
For a century the Punjab has sent its sons, and now its daughters, abroad. In Doaba there are villages of empty mansions built with money from England and Canada; in the Malwa, towns are full of English-language coaching centres for the students' visa to Canada and Australia. From Pakistani Punjab men go to the Gulf, Britain and Europe. Their remittances build houses and schools; the price is villages of the old, and young people who risk dangerous routes through agents to get out.
Drugs
Heroin smuggled across the border, and later synthetic drugs and pharmaceutical opioids, spread through Indian Punjab from the 2000s. Surveys, a 2016 film named Udta Punjab and the funerals of young men made it a national scandal and an election issue. Pakistani Punjab, on the same route from Afghanistan, has its own crisis. Both governments promise campaigns; families and village gurdwaras run their own de-addiction centres.
The Green Revolution and the water
Indian Punjab, 1960 – 2023Scroll sideways to see the whole figure →
Indian Punjab. Rice was a minor crop before the 1960s; high-yielding wheat and rice, tubewells and free farm power made the state India's granary and emptied its aquifers. Sources: R. S. Sidhu, Journal of Punjab Studies; Down to Earth, 1999; Mongabay India, 2023, citing the Central Ground Water Authority.
Sources: Government of Punjab and Government of Pakistan agricultural statistics; Central Ground Water Board; reporting in The Tribune, Dawn and The Indian Express.